Sales Insight: How to Cross the Credibility Threshold

November 21st, 2014

Gina is a super smart twenty-six year old. She just got her doctorate from Yale University. She wrote her doctorate thesis on the market evolution of a cutting edge tech product. Ultimately, Gina sees herself in academia, but she’s taken a sales job with an established high-flying tech startup that produces the product she did her thesis on. She wants to put some equity in the bank first.

Gina is about to meet with Arlen, the sixty-six year old CEO of a venerable family business based in Jackson, Mississippi. It’s her first trip to the deep South.

I don’t know about you, but I’m getting nervous for Gina.

Credibility Requires a Plan

What are the dynamics that might impact Gina’s ability to have a useful meeting with Arlen? She needs a plan.

If a person walked up to you on the street and asked you to describe your last bowel movement, you probably would look at them like they were crazy. But if your doctor asked you the same question, you’d be willing to do so. Why? Because, your doctor has credibility. You have faith that the information you transmit to him or her might end up being useful to you.

A key question for Gina, is ‘does she have credibility with Arlen’?
Before Gina walks into her meeting with Arlen, she has to ask herself. “Am I more like the doctor to Arlen, or am I more like the person on the street?” If it’s the latter, Arlen might not view Gina as credible at the start of the meeting. He might play things a little close to the vest. He might not tell Gina much about his company and its challenges right away. Gina might get questions as responses to her questions. Arlen might say things like…

“First, tell me more about what you do?”

“I’ve been in this business for over forty years. Why should we work with you?”

“We have relationships that go back decades, why should we change?”

“Now tell me. Is this your first time in Mississippi?”

Credibility is a Threshold Issue

Gina needs credibility. How much? Just enough so that Arlen will answer the questions Gina asks. You’re not going to get anywhere if your client doesn’t have enough confidence in you to answer your questions. Usually, you need to do something to establish that confidence; that allows you to start asking meaningful questions. (Ask good questions and your credibility will grow.) This seems obvious, but the reason credibility is so often overlooked is because much of the time you already have it. When your potential client said yes to your request for a meeting, they granted it to you. Perhaps, you were introduced to your client by someone they respect. Perhaps they contacted you. Maybe you’ve already illustrated your capacity to be useful. An important aspect of credibility for a salesperson, is being aware when you don’t have it with someone.

Three Ways to Cross the Credibility Threshold

In Never Be Closing, we present eight ways to cross the credibility threshold. For someone like Gina with Arlen, there are three that are most likely to help.

crossing the credibility threshold

crossing the credibility threshold

1. A referral. Gina, in her research studies, may have met and impressed some people who have standing in the industry who know Arlen. An email or a message from a shared contact extolling Gina and her research might be enough to open the professional disclosure door.

2. Cogent industry commentary. Gina wrote a thesis on the industry. She probably has some information, data, or conclusions that Arlen hasn’t yet seen or considered. Gina could start a dialog around an industry topic and interest Arlen in her thinking or research. She could create a presentation with data and analysis that she thinks might be useful to Arlen, and use it as a sounding board, a conversation starter for Arlen’s reactions. Gina needs Arlen to begin to offer his impressions and thoughts related to Gina’s presentation.

3. A tailored presentation. Having a prepared presentation is also a mechanism for taking the lead on the process of the meeting. And demonstrating a professional meeting process is a good way for a young or novice salesperson to establish credibility. Being overt about your process (this means you need to have a process and be able to cogently communicate it) is useful for novice salespeople. Seek to use your presentation as a platform for inquiry, not a show

And Gina, if you have an interest in college football, it can’t hurt to check the recent scores and upcoming SEC matchups. (Especially this year, as both Ole Miss and Mississippi State are at the top of the national rankings.)

Good luck Gina!

Join Tim in our upcoming webinar, How to Get INSTANT CREDIBILITY with the Best Prospects on 11/25 at 12pm ET. Register Now!.

What Legendary Coach Bear Bryant Can Teach Us About Selling

October 3rd, 2014

A team of academic researchers once asked Bear Bryant why Alabama football was so successful under his tenure. Bear Bryant's reply: “Because I love my players, and they love me.” The researchers were skeptical. Alabama football, like any team, was measured on wins and losses. The researchers theorized that the team’s won-loss record (or the amount of love they had for their coach) might not be the most useful measure or motivator for individual players Read More...

Cold Calling: 4 metrics that tell you if you should be.

September 1st, 2014

The battle over cold calling rages on. Is cold calling a necessary part of being a salesperson? Or should a good salesperson never be cold calling? The battle continues because the answer is contextual. Both of the above statements are true, depending on context. Whether cold calling is useful depends on your situation, your industry and your product Read More...

Selling is a Process

August 5th, 2014

Many years ago, my boss’s boss stopped me in the hallway. “Congratulations,” he said. I heard you had an application signed with Cargil. I was concerned. Since he knew the application had been signed, he would expect the transaction to close. “Well, it's not closed yet. Maybe wait until the money is in the bank to congratulate me Read More...

Door to Door

June 4th, 2014

We were expecting no one when the door bell rang at my mother’s house. I opened the door. The air was brisk, the wind was strong, the sun was burning bright. Standing at my mother’s front door was a young brown skinned man, wearing a frayed white oxford and dark blue pants that were slightly too big for him Read More...

In Your Dreams

April 4th, 2014

In the wee hours of the morning of May 5th, 2009, I spontaneously had to give a presentation on selling to a large room full of my old colleagues. There was no time to prepare. Speaking off the cuff, I gave an entertaining and interesting performance. I managed to poke fun at the bosses, and deliver some relevant content Read More...

Michael Porter and Sales Strategy

February 28th, 2014

"The essence of strategy is choosing what not to do, and not doing it." I'm a recent convert to Michael Porter's principal for strategic action. It solves the common problem inherent in unclear goals. If top line strategy and objectives are ambiguous or unclear, then mission creep sets in; we can justify lots of activities in the pursuit of those loosely defined goals Read More...

The Queen of Hearts

January 31st, 2014

In the card game of gin, each player tries to group his hand into three of a kind, or a run of three or more consecutive cards of the same suit, until all ten cards in the player's hand are part of a straight flush or three of a kind. My grandmother - I called her Nana - was a great gin player. The end of the game would always find her holding the cards I needed to win Read More...

What the French Can Teach Us About Customer Service

December 13th, 2013

The French? Really? On the surface, French customer service seems like an oxymoronic concept. Every culture has its code for unlocking customer service. If you use the code, you get better treatment. In the U.S. as you walk the aisles of a grocery store looking for Grey Poupon, what do you say to the clerk in the aisle if you need help? You say “Pardon me” (if you’re in the commercial), or “Excuse me Read More...

Sales teams and innovative organizations

November 8th, 2013

Where does innovation come from? The New Yorker recently featured an article on the topic of great white sharks. Giant, roaming hunting machines; white sharks have survived basically unchanged for hundreds of millions of years. They prowl the oceans alone covering thousands of miles. Because these sharks are such solitary creatures, there are still many things we have yet to learn about them Read More...